Rumbo · four minutes, no sign-up
Would your finance team catch this?
Below is a board commentary an AI assistant produced from the numbers next to it. It reads well. Find what is wrong with it.
You are the Financial Controller · Ferrolane Components Ltd
Your CFO has asked an AI assistant to draft the Q3 trading commentary for the board pack. She has forwarded it to you before it goes in. You have the numbers it was given.
- Ferrolane makes precision fasteners for the automotive aftermarket.
- Two revenue lines: contract manufacturing on annual agreements, and spot orders which are higher margin but unpredictable.
- The board meets on Thursday. Whatever goes in the pack becomes a document of record.
Q3 trading summary — £000s
| Line | Q3 actual | Q3 budget | Variance | Q2 actual |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contract revenue | 4,180 | 4,400 | -220 | 4,310 |
| Spot revenue | 1,290 | 1,050 | 240 | 1,120 |
| TOTAL REVENUE | 5,470 | 5,450 | 20 | 5,430 |
| Materials | 2,461 | 2,398 | 63 | 2,389 |
| Direct labour | 874 | 872 | 2 | 869 |
| TOTAL COST OF SALES | 3,335 | 3,270 | 65 | 3,258 |
| GROSS PROFIT | 2,135 | 2,180 | -45 | 2,172 |
| Distribution | 412 | 405 | 7 | 401 |
| Administration | 968 | 940 | 28 | 951 |
| TOTAL OVERHEADS | 1,380 | 1,345 | 35 | 1,352 |
| OPERATING PROFIT | 755 | 835 | -80 | 820 |
Variance is actual less budget. A positive variance on a cost line is unfavourable. Prepared from the UK ledger.
AI-generated · not checked by anyone
Prompt: “Draft the Q3 trading commentary for the board.”
Q3 revenue of £5.47m came in ahead of budget, with particularly strong performance in the spot order book which finished £240k above plan.
Operating profit of £755k was £80k behind budget, reflecting cost inflation in materials, where input prices rose roughly 6% during the quarter.
Gross margin was broadly stable at 39.0%. The business remains on track for the full year, and we expect the spot order strength seen in Q3 to continue into Q4.
Write as much or as little as you like. There is more than one thing.